Description
img{max-width:100%}
الاسم : كتاب حوار مع صديقي الملحد
تاريخ النشر : 1970
عن الكتاب : صديقى رجل يحب الجدل ويهوى الكلام وهو يعتقد أننا نحن المؤمنون السذج نقتات بالاوهام ونضحك على أنفسنا بالجنة والحوار العين وتفوتنا لذات الدنيا ومفاتنها.. وصديقى بهذه المناسبة تخرج من فرنسا وحصل على دكتوراه وعاش مع الهيبيز وأصبح ينكر كل شئ. قال لي ساخرًا : -انتم تقولون: ان الله موجود، وعمدة براهينكم هو قانون “السببية” الذى ينص على أن لكل صنعة صانعا ولكل خلق خالقاً ولكل وجود موجدا.. النسيج يدل على النساج والرسم على الرسام والنقش على النقاش والكون بهذا المنطق أبلغ دليل على الاله القدير الذى خلقه. صدقنا وآمنا بهذا الخالق.. ألا يحق لنا بنفس المنطق أن نسأل.. ومن خلق الخالق.. من خلق الله الذى تحدثوننا عنه.. ألا تقودنا نفس استدلالاتكم الى هذا.. وتبعا لنفس قانون السببية.. ما رأيكم فى هذا المطب دام فضلكم؟. ونحن نقول له: سؤالك فاسد.. ولا مطب ولا حاجة فأنت تسلم بأن الله خالق ثم تقول من خلقه؟! فتجعل منه خالقا ومخلوقا فى نفس الجملة وهذا تناقض، والوجه الآخر لفساد السؤال أنك تتصور خضوع الخالق لقوانين مخلوقاته.. فالسببية قانوننا نحن أبناء الزمان والمكان. والله الذى خلق الزمان والمكان هو بالضرورة فوق الزمان والمكان ولا يصح لنا أن نتصوره مقيدا بالزمان والمكان ولا بقوانين الزمان والمكان. والله هو الذى خلق قانون السببية فلا يجوز أن نتصوره خاضعا لقانون السببية الذى خلقه، وأنت بهذه السفسطة أشبه بالعرائس التى تتحرك بزمبلك وتتصور أن الانسان الذى صنعها لابد هو الآخر يتحرك بزمبلك.. فاذا قلنا لها بل هو يتحرك من تلقاء نفسه.. قالت: مستحيل أن يتحرك شئ من تلقاء نفسه.. انى أرى فى عالمى كل شئ يتحرك بزمبلك، وأنت بالمثل لا تتصور أن الله موجود بذاته بدون موجد.. لمجرد أنك ترى كل شئ حولك فى حاجة الى موجد
الموضوع : حوار مع صديقي الملحد كتاب من تأليف الفيلسوف والطبيب مصطفى محمود، صدر سنة 1986، يرد فيه على أسئلة لملحدين عن الدين الإسلامي، وعن تساؤلات مادية قد يطرحها العقل البشري في فترة ما
الكتاب يصف محاورة فكرية بين الدكتور مصطفى محمود وصديق خيالي ملحد، يطرح الأسئلة الإلحادية المعروفة مثل: “هل الله موجود؟” و”من خلق الله؟” ويقوم مصطفى محمود بالاجابة العلمية بشكل منطقي على العديد من هذه الأسئلة
Name : Dialogue With My Atheist Friend Book
Author : Dr. Mustafa Mahmoud
Publishing Date : 1970
Genre : Religious,Philosophical
Pages Number : 144
About The Book : My friend is a man who loves controversy and loves to talk, and he thinks that we, the naive believers, crave delusions and laugh at ourselves with paradise and eye dialogue, and we miss the same world and its charms … He said to me sarcastically: – You say: God exists, and the mayor of your proofs is the law of “causality” which states that every workman has a creator, every creation is a creator, and every existence is present. The Almighty God who created it. Believe us and believe in this Creator … Is it not right for us to ask .. Who created the Creator .. Who created God who you talked to us about … Do not the same your inferences lead you to this .. And according to the same law of causation .. What do you think of this plea as long as you please? . We say to him: Your question is corrupt … there is no need or need, for you recognize that God is a Creator and then say who created him ?! You make him a creator and a creature in the same sentence and this is a contradiction, and the other side of the corruption of the question is that you envision the creator being subject to the laws of his creatures .. Causality is our law, we are children of time and space. And God, who created time and space, is necessarily above time and space, and it is not correct for us to envision it bound by time and space, nor by the laws of time and space. And God is the one who created the law of causation, so it is not permissible to imagine it subject to the law of causation that created it, and you with this sophistry are more like brides who move in your times and imagine that the person who made them must also move in your times .. if we say to them but he is moving on his own .. she said: impossible To move something on its own .. I see in my world everything that moves on your zimbal, and you likewise do not imagine that God exists by itself without a Master .. just because you see everything around you in need of a Master
About The Writer : Mostafa Mahmoud (December 27, 1921 – October 31, 2009), Egyptian philosopher, physician, and writer. He is Mustafa Kemal Mahmoud Hussein Al Mahfouz, from Al-Ashraf and ends with his lineage to Ali Zain Al-Abidin. His father died in 1939 after years of paralysis, he studied medicine and graduated in 1953 and specialized in chest diseases, but he devoted himself to writing and research in 1960. He married in 1961 and the marriage ended in divorce in 1973. Two children, Amal and Adham, were born. He remarried in 1983 to Mrs. Zainab Hamdi, and this marriage also ended in divorce in 1987
He wrote 89 books, including scientific, religious, philosophical, social and political books, in addition to tales, plays and excursions, and his style is attractive with depth and simplicity.
Dr. Mustafa Mahmoud presented more than 400 episodes of his famous TV program (Science and Faith), and in 1979 he established his mosque in Cairo, known as the “Mustafa Mahmoud Mosque”. He is affiliated with three medical centers that are concerned with the treatment of people with low incomes, and many Egyptians go to because of their medical reputation, and he formed convoys of mercy from sixteen doctors, and the center includes four astronomical observatories and a museum of geology, on which specialized professors depend. The museum includes a group of granite rocks, butterflies stuffed with various forms and some marine creatures, and the correct name of the mosque is “Mahmoud” and he called it the name of his father
Subject : A dialogue with my atheist friend, a book written by the philosopher and physician Mustafa Mahmoud, published in 1986, in which he answers questions of atheists about the Islamic religion, and about material questions that the human mind may ask in a period
The book describes an intellectual conversation between Dr. Mustafa Mahmoud and a fictional atheist friend, asking well-known atheistic questions such as: “Does God exist?” And “Who created God?” Mustafa Mahmoud logically answers many of these questions
